Does WordPress Need 1000s of Block Themes in the Era of Full Site Editing? – WP Tavern


“I have so many design ideas in my head that I am about to make it my mission to singlehandedly fulfill [Matt Mullenweg’s] vision of 5,000 Full Site Editing #WordPress themes in the directory,” tweeted Brian Gardner earlier today.

Daniel Schutzsmith responded:

I’m just not seeing the need for more than one theme for FSE as long as I can override the look of it.

Would appreciate someone explaining why one theme like @frostwp COULDN’T just be the standard.</…….

“I’ve so many design ideas in my head That I am about to make it my mission to singlehandedly fulfill [Matt Mullenweg’s] imaginative and prescient of 5,000 Full Website Modifying #WordPress themes Inside the listing,” tweeted Brian Gardner earlier right now.

Daniel Schutzsmith responded:

I’m simply not seeing The want for A quantity of theme for FSE As prolonged as I can override the look of it.

Would respect somebody explaining why one theme like @frostwp COULDN’T simply be The regular.

Making extra themes really feels Choose it defeats the idea of FSE alcollectively.

It is not The primary time somebody requested whether or not A quantity of block theme Is important. In 2019, Rich Tabor proposed including a base theme to WordPress itself, one upon which completely differents Can be constructed, if In any respect.

Even that was not The primary time somebody had contemplated comparable one-theme uprimeias all by way of the platform’s historic previous. Many framework-type mother or father themes have all made a run for it.

Permit us To imagine for a second that WordPress has reached a state the place All of themes Not want custom-made PHP and CSS code. We’re nothe place shut to That time but, however We will think about such a day Might be potential Inside the comparatively distant future. On this best world, templating, styling, theme-assisted options, and plugin integration are neatly packaged into one factor configurable from the admin. In apply, clients could administration any facet of their site’s entrance-finish by way of the interface.

The drawback is That somebody nonethemuch less Should make these custom-madeizations, And by no means everyone has a knack for design. One particular person’s capability Does not mechanically translate to all completely different clients.

Maybe a extra essential level is that not everyone Desires to custom-madeise their site’s design. Some people merely Need to Search out one factor that matches their type and transfer aprolongedside.

There are various routes for arriving On The identical vacation spot, however themes are presently The one reliable car.

Schutzsmith tweeted The subsequent in response to Jamie Marsland, who likened the notion to asking Picasso for the canvas Rather than the accomplished painting:

Themes and swapping out The complete factor is an previous Thoughts-set. Constructive a theme could = painting however I’m saying why can’t we simply swap out the theme.json and get The identical Outcome? Why The want for themes In any respect when all We now have To vary is theme.json.

Which will be a future that I might not mind striving for. It is not insurmountable, however There’s an uphill climb that WordPress will undoubtedly wrestle with. And not using a regularized CSS toolpackage in place, switching theme.json information merely Does not work. If …….

Source: https://wptavern.com/does-wordpress-need-1000s-of-block-themes-in-the-era-of-full-site-editing